Today is Town Meeting Day in Vermont (and what that has to do with civil politics)
The Village Square recently kicked off an initiative called "Our Town," with a goal to revive a local town hall (both in person and online). Our first event was 225+ standing-room-only, livestreamed by the local newspaper and live-tweeted, so we are off to a good start. We were lucky enough to have stellar partners in the Tallahassee Democrat and Leadership Tallahassee, but also central to our success was framing the programs as central to ideals we share, despite political divisions that also exist. Once we define ourselves as in community with our neighbors (The Righteous Mind’s groupish “hive”), everything starts to change. The pizza also didn't hurt as in our experience sharing a meal immediately defines a shared community. We have learned repeatedly that for minds to change, hearts must open first. Below is the editorial printed ahead of the event in the Tallahassee Democrat; it is our direct appeal to hearts.
There’s nothing more quintessentially American than a town hall meeting. It’s how the business of American community has gotten done from just about the moment the first disaffected European foot hit ground in the New World.
Even if you’ve never attended one, the town meeting is buried so deep in our country’s psyche that you can probably immediately call up its intimate details – rows of folding chairs, town council up front with only a school lunch table to define their status, a charmless but functional meeting room. Someone probably saw to it that there would be coffee and cookies. Overachievers might organize a potluck.
Colorful characters are always in attendance, because we’re a country full of colorful characters.
Nowhere in the world is the town meeting more central to a nation’s story. There’s a legitimate reason for this, as it is a perfect manifestation of the fundamental shift from European monarchy to governance by and for the people. In this new country without a king to issue edicts, someone was going to have to make a few decisions.
To be sure, muddling through local governance issues isn’t our first choice on how to spend an evening. There are grievances that aren’t ours, people who drone on too long, chairs that occasionally are thrown in anger, and a tangled web of alternatives that can make even a wonky constable’s head throb. All in all, town meetings are pretty sloppy affairs. But then so is democracy. The messiness is a small price to avoid nasty kings with guillotines.
Within the ethos of the town meeting is the important founding principle that political foes must grudgingly become partners as they engage conflicting ideas in order to govern. But unlike our founding generation who had no choice but to roll up their sleeves and do the uncomfortable but necessary work of dealing with disagreement face-to-face, these days we’re having fewer conversations of substance with people who don’t see things our way. Bunkered up at home with our favorite websites and news station, it’s become so much easier to vilify the people we used to share our meetings with. It’s left us feeling less compelled to suffer through the vicissitudes of the town meeting.
In an environment of “tribal” information sources, local disagreements tend to be seen simplistically through the prism of the divide on national issues, as skirmishes in a countrywide partisan war rather than the unique and complex local situations they usually are. It’s our national dysfunction taken root in hometown America, and it’s not helping us make good decisions where we live.
So at the very time when we most need to bring our “A” game to solving civic problems, our conversations too often consist of stomping on toes, throwing sand, and various other playground antics. When a town hall meeting is held, it tends to become a venue for villagers with pitchforks (rude signs anyway) to vent their rage.
In the seven years since we first dreamed up the notion of The Village Square – an organization dedicated to restoring constructive conversation across the partisan divide – we repeatedly return to the same truth: Washington is never going to fix this for us. If we want it to be different, it’s going to be neighbors like us in hometowns like this one who get it done. This is where we share carpools, softball teams and borrow cups of sugar.
It’s only in our town where we can have the messy, quirky, spectacularly American conversation of democracy.
We think it’s about time we bring back the humble town hall. We’re calling our 21st century version “Our Town,” but it’s really the same old-fashioned idea that built this country. In the coming years we’ll be hosting a regular series of unique neighborly (and possibly even entertaining) get-togethers all about where we live.
We’re convinced it’s America’s ideal writ large when her hometowns are healthy and tended to. In fact, we hope that one day we can teach Washington a thing or two. In a country by and for the people, isn’t that exactly how it should be?
— Liz Joyner
Please check out the very early development of our nationwide online Get Local project by clicking on first Florida, then Tallahassee. Later in the project, we'll make pages like these available for every state and community. It's a fully user-editable (like Wikipedia), totally scalable (from neighborhoods to international) public policy wiki. Our goal: Civilized debate on the internet. (Wish us luck…)